SLECC Key Challenges and State and Local Solutions Database

Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
Challenge

Resilience Planning Excludes Indigenous, Tribal, and Frontline Leadership. Resilience planning often marginalizes Indigenous knowledge, Tribal sovereignty, and the lived experience of frontline, rural, immigrant, and unhoused communities. Structural, geographic, cultural, and logistical barriers—including misaligned timelines, language access gaps, digital inequities, and exclusion from regional decision-making—prevent authentic leadership and result in strategies disconnected from on-the-ground conditions.

Region: San Francisco Bay Area, Central Coast, San Joaquin Valley, San Diego, Statewide
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
Challenge

Transactional Engagement and Trust Deficits Undermine Participation. Resilience engagement is often tied to short-term grants or one-off processes, resulting in shallow participation that devalues lived and Indigenous knowledge. Historic harms, competitive funding, generational disinvestment, and safety concerns—particularly for undocumented residents—have eroded trust, reducing community willingness to engage or sustain involvement in resilience planning.

Region: San Francisco Bay Area, Central Coast, San Joaquin Valley, San Diego, Statewide
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
State Solution

State should fund sustained, community-led engagement infrastructure (supporting trusted CBOs and tribal organizations as long-term partners for a minimum of three to five years rather than through episodic contracts) meeting communities where they are rather than requiring them to navigate government processes.

Region: San Francisco Bay Area, Central Coast, San Diego, Statewide
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
Local Solution

Build citizen oversight structures into climate planning projects that give affected residents genuine decision-making power rather than advisory roles. 

Existing Examples of Progress: The Pajaro Valley TCC's Community Climate Coalition, composed of local residents and nonprofit representatives, is a documented example of this structure in practice.
Further Progress Pathways: Establishing standing advisory bodies, community steering groups, and regional coordination tables where CBOs, Tribes, and local governments collaborate with state and regional agencies on climate-resilience strategies.
Region: San Francisco Bay Area, Central Coast, San Joaquin Valley, San Diego
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
Local Solution

Integrate Indigenous Knowledge and Leadership as Core Resilience Expertise. Local and regional resilience planning should recognize Traditional Ecological Knowledge and lived experience as foundational expertise by centering Indigenous leadership and stewardship practices through long-term, compensated partnerships. Authentic application of practices such as cultural burning and land stewardship strengthens fire resilience, adaptation outcomes, and trust.

Region: San Francisco Bay Area, San Joaquin Valley, San Diego, Statewide
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
Challenge

Power Imbalances Undermine Community-Led Resilience. Resilience efforts where institutions or a handful of people retain decision-making authority while community-based organizations and residents are asked to provide input without shared power or control limit community ownership of resilience outcomes.

Region: Central Coast, San Joaquin Valley, Statewide
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
Local Solution

Local governments should map existing community relationships and tailor engagement approaches to local cultural context — particularly for Tribal and rural communities — before implementing solutions, preventing parachute approaches that bypass community infrastructure and trust. 

Region: San Joaquin Valley, San Diego, Statewide
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
State Solution

Recognize and Institutionalize Indigenous Knowledge as State-Level Resilience Expertise. The state should formally recognize Traditional Ecological Knowledge and lived experience as legitimate resilience expertise—particularly for fire, land stewardship, and ecosystem-based adaptation—and operationalize this shift by removing administrative barriers, compensating Tribal practitioners, and funding long-term partnerships that center Indigenous leadership in regional and local resilience planning.

Region: San Francisco Bay Area, Statewide
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
Local Solution

Co-Lead Resilience Efforts with Trusted Community Partners. Local governments can partner with trusted, culturally rooted CBOs—including promotoras, Tribal partners, youth networks, and faith-based groups—to co-design and deliver resilience activities using multilingual, trauma-informed approaches in community-based settings, improving participation and relevance for frontline residents.

Region: San Francisco Bay Area, Statewide
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
Challenge

Community-based organizations face severe capacity constraints, compounded by siloed and duplicative agency engagement: CBOs are underfunded, administratively overburdened, and stretched thin while multiple agencies approach them separately with overlapping requests.

Region: San Francisco Bay Area, San Joaquin Valley
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
State Solution

Fund multi-year, flexible engagement efforts that recognize relationship-building as essential work—covering community stipends, access supports, and the sustained time and resources needed to build trust with frontline, Indigenous, rural, and immigrant communities.

Region: San Francisco Bay Area, San Diego
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
State Solution

Resource and strengthen trusted-messenger networks at both state and local levels—providing multilingual outreach tools, hybrid/in-person communication channels, and long-term partnerships with trusted community navigators and CBOs—to ensure climate engagement is culturally rooted, non-extractive, and accessible to all residents.

Existing Examples of Progress: Climate Science Alliance is an organization facilitating collaborative, community-based climate initiatives in the San Diego region. Their work was presented as a trusted convener and connector between local communities, tribes, and scientific partners.
Region: San Francisco Bay Area, San Diego
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
Local Solution

Local entities should invest in long-term sustained relationship building with marginalized, tribal, and rural communities (requiring early and authentic engagement rather than check-box participation tied to grant cycles) recognizing that trust takes years to build and can be destroyed by a single instance of data misuse or broken commitment.

Region: San Joaquin Valley, San Diego
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
Best Practice

The Yak Tityu Tityu Yak Tiłhini (YTT) Northern Chumash Tribe and the City of San Luis Obispo demonstrate what meaningful tribal inclusion in local climate planning can look like when consultation is treated as relationship-building rather than procedural compliance. When the City updated its climate adaptation and safety element in 2022, a new sustainability staff member used SB 18’s tribal consultation requirement as an opportunity to deepen an existing but shallow relationship — writing YTT directly into the vegetation management and traditional ecological knowledge sections of the open space plan as leads on climate resilience work, rather than placing tribal content only in the environmental justice section.

This planning foundation enabled the region’s first cultural burn within City open space in June 2024 — a 15-acre burn on a popular hiking trail conducted in partnership with CAL FIRE and Sequoia River Lands Trust. YTT is now developing a 14-year cultural burn plan for their homelands, supported by state and conservancy grants that the planning partnership helped make accessible, with goals including native species promotion, invasive management, and community reconnection with fire.

Region: Central Coast
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
Local Solution

Engage tribes not only in environmental justice sections but as domain experts and leaders on vegetation management, land stewardship, and climate resilience; expanding their role beyond diversity inclusion into substantive planning authority. 

Existing Examples of Progress: The YTT Northern Chumash tribe was written specifically into the City of SLO's climate adaptation plan as leads on vegetation management and traditional ecological knowledge in city open space, enabled by SB 18's tribal consultation requirement for general plan updates.
Further Progress Pathways: SB 18's tribal consultation requirement for general plan and specific plan updates provides an existing mechanism for jurisdictions to initiate and deepen these relationships.
Region: Central Coast
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
Challenge

The immigration status of a significant portion of the Central Coast’s agricultural workforce creates a structural barrier to climate planning participation, as fear of government-connected processes — including surveys, public meetings, and program enrollment — chills engagement among the frontline communities most exposed to climate hazards like heat, drought, and poor air quality.

  • Illustrative example: In the Pajaro Valley, the TCC planning team explicitly limited data collection to anonymous, non-identifying information and prioritized relationship-building over formal participation processes specifically to create safety for undocumented residents — yet even these adaptations were insufficient to fully overcome the fear generated by the current immigration enforcement environment.
Region: Central Coast
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
Challenge

Indigenous and landless tribes face particular barriers to meaningful engagement, including grant contract terms that conflict with sovereignty, lack of advance funding, and reimbursement delays that make participation financially impossible without unrestricted reserves.

Region: Central Coast
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
State Solution

Providing technical assistance and facilitation support for community-led resilience efforts. State participants discussed the need for facilitation, coordination, and technical assistance to help communities engage meaningfully in resilience planning and preparedness. This support is framed as enabling participation rather than directing outcomes.

Region: Statewide
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
State Solution

Fund resilience hub retrofits, site improvements, local procurement pathways, and grants that enable community facilities to function as resilience and engagement centers.

Region: San Francisco Bay Area
Leave Feedback!
Priority Area: Community Resilience
Barrier: Inclusive Planning
Local Solution

Strengthen CBO capacity through administrative support, staffing resources, and coordinated technical assistance. Provide back-office support, reporting assistance, and shared staffing so CBOs can participate meaningfully in resilience planning.

Region: San Francisco Bay Area
Leave Feedback!

Help us strengthen our knowledge base!

Help us to expand this database. Either share new ideas, best practices or general feedback via this form, or click on a particular item to share additional feedback, information, examples of progress on that particular item.

Use these filters to drill down on priority areas, barriers, challenge or solution type, and/or regions.

Filters
Topic Areas
Reset
Barriers
Reset
Type
Reset
Region
Reset